Click here to see this email on your browser.
Böll EU Newsletter 10/2024
After the 'super election year': A whole new world?

Dear friends,

2024 was the year of the vote; more than 100 countries, representing nearly half of the global population, held elections this year. 2025 will be the year of political work, with governments implementing the policies and promises made. In this context, one central question is emerging: What is the role of the state and government in an era defined by profound political, economic and environmental challenges? And what capacity do governments have to deal with them?

Divergent visions to these questions are crystallising. One vision is championed by figures like Javier Milei in Argentina or Elon Musk in the US. They foresee radical cuts to the administration, a minimal, deregulated state that lets wild capitalism and private entrepreneurship solve all challenges. Milei’s “chainsaw” and Musk’s DOGE (Department for Government Efficiency) – which draws inspiration from the cryptocoin Shiba Inu dog – are symbolic for this vision. The chainsaw for the destruction of the state, the dogecoin for the wild entrepreneurship.

This libertarian narrative is gaining traction in Europe. Calls for less government intervention and cuts to administration are getting louder in Brussels. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen’s Mission Letters and Political Guidelines echo a soft version, highlighting the simplification of bureaucratic procedures and a reduction of administrative burden and reporting requirements. In early 2025, the European Commission is planning to introduce an Omnibus Simplification Package, aiming to streamline sustainability regulations. 

Of course, streamlining processes, reducing duplications and increasing administrative efficiency is desirable and needed. But let’s not be naïve: There are political actors who, under the guise of a bureaucracy reduction agenda, aim to reduce the role of the state, deregulate and eliminate crucial environmental laws and regulations of the European Green Deal. Such an agenda must naturally be opposed. 

But one shouldn’t only play defence. What is needed is a progressive vision for reducing bureaucracy and of an effective state. At the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union, we aim to contribute to this debate, for example, with an upcoming analysis in 2025 of the planned Omnibus Simplification agenda.

As we finish the year, I would also like to take the opportunity to thank you, our readers, for your interest and continued support. We value your engagement and feedback and look forward to keeping you informed of our work and contributions in 2025! 

This last month, we are particularly proud to have supported Bruegel in looking into the role financial markets can play when it comes to protecting biodiversity, publishing an article by our Warsaw colleagues who highlight what we can expect from Poland’s EU Council Presidency, analysing what a Trump 2.0 administration means for Europe and support for Ukraine, looking back at Green parties' electoral scores in 2024, and presenting two final podcasts of the year – one with civil society leaders from Argentina evaluating one year of Milei’s presidency, and one with Reinhard Bütikofer, former Member of the European Parliament, looking into the past and future trajectory of the European Union and European Green Deal. We hope these find your interest! 

Our team wishes you a relaxing holiday season and a good start to the new year.

Warm regards,

Highlights

E-paper | Trump 2.0 and European cohesion: Scenario implications for Ukraine and transatlantic security

Over the last three years, the transatlantic alliance has demonstrated a largely remark-able unity in its support for Ukraine. Though the support has often been less ambitious and slower than Kyiv has needed, it has at least enabled Ukraine’s continued resistance against Russian aggression. 

As the war is soon to enter its fourth year, however, sup-port is eroding. And the future of US policy under President Trump is particularly uncertain. Given this context, this paper explores how the European Union and its Member States could adjust their Ukraine and NATO policies. It plots out Trump's potential administration policies on key questions related to support for Ukraine and NATO, as well as possible European responses and potential outcomes along the variables of unity and decisiveness.

This e-paper is an updated version of the publication “US elections and European cohesion” from October 2024 that contained scenarios for both a Harris and a Trump 2.0 administration" by Rachel Tausendfreund (DGAP) and Roderick Kefferpütz (Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung EU). The initial scenarios were refined, tested and reviewed in an online workshop with foreign policy and security experts.

 

Reactions to Trump's re-election from around the world

After the elections in the United States on 5 November 2024, the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung Washington, DC office reached out to the global network of Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung offices to hear how the second Trump administration will impact countries and progress on green issues across the world.

 

Poland’s EU Council Presidency - What to expect?

On 1 January 2025, Poland will take over the six-month presidency of the Council of the EU. As part of the presidency, it will host nearly 400 councils, meetings, and conferences with the participation of representatives from 27 countries. Contrary to a common misconception, this role does not grant Poland the authority to dictate the EU's actions. Instead, the Presidency is tasked with shaping the agenda of Council meetings, which can influence the priorities during this period and set the tone for the Council's overall working dynamic. The timing of Poland’s Presidency is significant, coinciding with the start of a new three-year EU funding period 2025-2027. Poland will also inherit the role from Hungary, whose Prime Minister, Viktor Orbán, has been criticized for endorsing the Russian narrative and dismantling democracy in his own country. The following article by the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung Warsaw office provides insights into Poland’s priorities during the six month period.

 

2024 in review: Green parties face mixed fortunes amid anti-government backlash

2024 was a challenging year for any government’s ruling party. Incumbent governments struggled as the cost-of-living crisis disgruntled voters around the globe. This was especially true for junior coalition partners, who often bear the brunt of electoral backlash. Green parties – whose electoral performance is closely linked to a country’s economy – were no exception to the rule this year. This article reviews the performance of European Green Party (EGP) affiliates in elections in Europe in 2024, drawing the conclusion that those in government suffered while those in opposition did less so. Analysis by Eric Balonwu (EuropeElects).

 

Policy brief | What role for skills mobility in the green agri-food transition?

As the EU enters a new five-year cycle, its ambitious Green Deal targets and European Climate Law face growing uncertainty due to concerns over industrial competitiveness and economic growth. Additionally, backlash against the EU’s climate policies, fuelled by farmers’ protests, could hinder the promise of a just green transition.

Yet, as the planet warms rapidly, climate change will continue to affect EU economic sectors, including agriculture and food. Greater climate variability and extremes will impact global food systems, posing supply chain challenges and heightening food insecurity. These trends highlight the need to invest in sustainable agri-food systems as part of climate mitigation and adaptation. With an ageing population and demographic shifts, this transition rests on a stable workforce with both traditional and ‘green’ skills in the EU and beyond.

The OECD reports that the EU agri-food sector currently has a high rate of skills mismatch and is set to lose a further 13% of its skilled workers, mostly low-skilled, in the next decade.2 Beyond seasonal and temporary farm workers, the sector will need medium to high-skilled workers, not all of whom can be sourced domestically or via reskilling efforts. Furthermore, the Green Deal alone is expected to create an estimated 2.5 million more jobs by 2030. By Helena Hahn (European Policy Centre).

 

Now available in English! Böll.Thema 24-2 | Democracy: Diverse avenues towards one common goal

Globally, democracy is under pressure. In this issue of the Böll.Thema magazine, we introduce individuals who inspire us with their dedication to democratic values. Because without dedication and action, there can be no democracy. And without democracy, everything is for naught.

Read more
 

Podcasts

Böll·Europe Podcast #21 | Reinhard Bütikofer on Europe, foreign policy and the Green movement

Roderick Kefferpütz, Director of the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung EU talks to Reinhard Bütikofer. He was Member of the European Parliament for the Green/EFA group for 15 years, from 2009 to 2024. During his time at the European Parliament, Reinhard Bütikofer focused on foreign affairs, international trade, and EU-China relations. He served as the chair of the EP delegation for relations with China and was a long-standing member of the delegation for relations with the United States. As Co-Chair of the European Green Party from 2012 to 2019, and as a Leader of the German Green Party from 2002 to 2008, he played an important role in shaping Green policies in Europe. In this episode, they delve into his insights on evolving global challenges, the trajectory of Green EU policies, and the future of EU-China relations, in a conversation filled with reflections, and strategies for addressing pressing global issues.

Listen on Podigee | Spotify | Apple | YouTube
 

The Sound of Economics | Nature on the balance sheet: a financial perspective

How can businesses, governments and financial institutions work together to tackle the global biodiversity crisis? In this episode of The Sound of Economics, Rebecca Christie invites Heather Grabbe and Thomas Viegas to explore the intersection of biodiversity and economic policy. The discussion highlights the critical importance of integrating nature conservation into financial frameworks. The guests delve into systemic risks posed by biodiversity loss, the role of public and private finance, and strategies to address harmful subsidies. They also emphasize the necessity of aligning economic systems with natural limits to ensure sustainable development and long-term resilience. This podcast was produced with the financial support of the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union.

Listen to the episode
 

Böll·Europe Podcast #20 | One year of Milei: what is going on in Argentina?

In 2023, Javier Milei, a self-described “anarcho-capitalist” surprised Argentina’s political establishment and won the presidential elections. He’s an admirer of US President-elect Donald Trump and of tech mogul Elon Musk, and his political platform is characterised by hash austerity and a very conservative social agenda. Using the rulebook of other illiberal regimes throughout the world when it comes to political communications and dealing with pluralism, his style and policies are making waves worldwide. What is going on in Argentina and what are the implications for human rights, digital rights and the environment? Joan Lanfranco, Head of Communications and Outreach at the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung EU office, explores these dimensions with Argentinian civil society representatives Cecilia Ales, Beatriz Busaniche and Ariel Slipak, who visited Brussels in November 2024 to present their case to key EU decision-makers and stakeholders.

Listen on Podigee | Spotify | Apple | YouTube
 
Photo credits:
Laurent Nyssen for Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung EU, All rights reserved
Christian Offenberg – IMAGO, All rights reserved
Kancelaria Premiera RP, CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0
 Markus Pfaff | Shutterstock, All rights reserved
State, Berlin, All Rights reserved

The Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung is a German political foundation affiliated with the German Green Party (Alliance 90/The Greens). Its primary task is political education and advocacy in Germany and abroad. Our main tenets are ecology and sustainability, democracy and human rights, non-violence and justice. In our work, we place particular emphasis on gender democracy, equal rights for minorities and the political and social participation of migrants.

Our namesake, the writer and Nobel Prize laureate Heinrich Böll, personifies the fundamental principles we stand for: defence of freedom and human dignity, civic courage, open debate and the acknowledgement of art and culture as independent spheres of thought and action. As a think tank for green visions and ideas, we are part of an international network with 34 offices worldwide and with partner projects in more than 60 countries.

The Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union represents the foundation vis-à-vis European and international institutions, associations, non-governmental organisations and media based in Brussels. The office is a main point of contact for individuals, groups and organisations from around the world interested in EU politics and policies. The future of the European project and the role of the European Union in the world are at the centre of our activities and efforts.

If you don't want to receive any more messages (to: unknown@noemail.com), you can unsubscribe here at any time.
Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union
Rue du Luxembourg, 47-51
B-1050 Brussels
Belgium

Joan.Lanfranco@eu.boell.org
Website

Your personal data is confidential and will not be forwarded to Third parties according to our Privacy Policy.